I don’t think either of them is a magic, because
1) Gills (fins on the underneath) are pretty coarse, a bit pale for the size (they darken as the mushroom ages so the really little ones fresh ones are similar colour). But, if you look on the top, there are fine dark lines running from the centre to the edge. Magics are much more uniform in colour and generally don’t show that kind of patterning.
I can’t see liberty caps (nipples on the top) of either of them but that doesn’t mean they are NOT there, just that I can’t see them! 🙂
