Forums › Life › Politics, Media & Current Events › Jewish group denounces rave video on Auschwitz
Jewish group denounces video on Auschwitz
Posted on Wed, Aug. 10, 2005
http://www.mercurynews.com/mld/mercurynews/news/breaking_news/12350153.htm
JOCELYN GECKER
Associated Press
PARIS – An Internet video that depicts the Nazi death camp Auschwitz as a rave party drew sharp criticism Wednesday from a Jewish rights group, which urged authorities to have it removed from European Web sites.
The three-minute video titled “Housewitz” – a pun on house music and Auschwitz – casts Nazi soldiers as DJs. It alternates black-and-white still photos of Holocaust atrocities with color images of youths at an outdoor party. And it advertises a “Free taxi ride home,” showing a wheelbarrow full of corpses.
The Simon Wiesenthal Center’s European office denounced the video as “outrageous,” saying it goes “beyond the bounds of freedom of expression to an unprecedented level of obscenity.”
The center asked the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe to call on countries where Web sites have posted the video to “immediately stop the spread of this pernicious nihilism.”
Jaroslaw Mensfeld, a spokesman for the museum at the Auschwitz Memorial in Poland, said he was “absolutely shocked.” Some 1.5 million people, mostly Jews, were killed at the Nazi camp during World War II. “I don’t understand how a person can make such a movie,” he said.
The film is featured on one Dutch and two Polish Web sites, the Wiesenthal Center said.
The Dutch Web site, Geenstijl, says it’s doing nothing wrong in posting the video. The site, whose name means “no style,” says it mixes news with “light subjects and pleasantly twisted nonsense.” It has published a disclaimer saying it copied the video after learning it was being talked about in Internet chat rooms.
“We didn’t make the video, but it is an integral part of the discussion by our viewers. It’s not illegal and we don’t intend to remove it from the site,” said Oscar van Wijland, one of the Web site’s writers.
According to the Dutch Complaints Bureau for Discrimination on the Internet, the video’s maker is a 22-year-old Dutch student. Six weeks ago, the bureau received a complaint about the video and had it pulled from three Web sites.
Later, when the Geenstijl site posted the film, the complaints bureau went to the Amsterdam Public Prosecutor but was told the video was “not illegal enough” to prosecute, the bureau said. It plans to appeal.
—
Associated Press Writer Arthur Max in Amsterdam contributed to this report.
alright, its a touchy subject, but as woody allen said : tragedy plus time equals comedy, so theyre just sticking to the rules.
it scares me when people say that stuff goes beyond freedom of expression, as i dont think expression should have limits, just should be open to debate. so long as other people have the oppotunity to say their two cents about the film and put it in context, i cant see a problem.
This is kind of similar to when the scene with the twin towers was taken out of the Spiderman movie.
We all know that terrible things happened there, just as we know about Auschwitz. But should we forget and then pretend it never happened?
Recently, because of the anniversary, there’s been a lot in the press about Hiroshima & Nagasaki, some of what I’ve read has been lighthearted, even funny. I don’t remember hearing about anyone trying to ban these publications, not even the Japanese, when an estimated 10,000 people died in a matter of seconds in Hiroshima alone at the hands of the Allies, well, America anyway.
I believe humour & art are expressions of the intelligent – if I don’t get a joke, maybe I just don’t understand, it doesn’t mean that it’s wrong.
Aside from all of that, I’ve seen many pictures of post-war Auschwitz, and it would be a brilliant place to have a party.
peace
the use of WW II footage for humour was actually going on during the war!
Spike Milligan (who fought in the war) made all these mad comedy shows during the early 1980s, and he always used to slip in a short film called “the lambeth goose step”
This wasn’t a new form of dancing to garage or grime in South London but a black and white film from wartime which showed Hitler goosestepping in time to Cockney music “the lambeth walk” – it was the sort of film they’d show in the cinemas when he was on leave as a morale-booster to the troops and he thought it would still be amusing 40 years later (which it was)
in fact much of Spike Milligans bizzare sense of humour comes from his wartime experiences….
I can understand the brouhaha though, there is a worry that particularly in the netherlands the techno scene is being infiltrated by the extreme right…
but it does seem at present [as no evidence has yet emerged that the video maker was a supporter of fascist politics] looking at the wider picture this film was just made using random bits of footage.
I’ve made videos with D&B soundtracks and loads of war scenes, atomic bomb footage and crime footage (particularly UK police chases), but I am not a fascist or someone who likes war…
0
Voices
2
Replies
Tags
This topic has no tags
Forums › Life › Politics, Media & Current Events › Jewish group denounces rave video on Auschwitz