Forums › Life › Politics, Media & Current Events › UK : Greens PPB trashed by media incompetence
if the Greens are not given another PPB slot, an apology caption and financial compensation from both C4 and Auntie for this fuckup, then I would suggest all their supporters make a formal complaint to Ofcom about this.
[font=arial,helvetica,sans-serif]Ukip goes Green in C4 election blunder[/font]
[font=Geneva,Arial,sans-serif] Julia Day
Friday April 29, 2005[/font] [font=Geneva,Arial,sans-serif]Channel 4 has been forced to apologise to the Green party after mistakenly transmitting its election broadcast with subtitles from the UK Independence Party.[/font][font=Geneva,Arial,sans-serif]Last night’s broadcast, promoting the party’s vision of a green future, was directed by Repo Man film-maker Alex Cox and set to a Franz Ferdinand soundtrack. [/font]
[font=Geneva,Arial,sans-serif]But subtitles for a Ukip broadcast, which cursed the European Union, were screened simultaneously.[/font]
[font=Geneva,Arial,sans-serif]The Greens are furious that some viewers may now think they take Ukip’s negative stance on Europe, immigration and political correctness.[/font]
[font=Geneva,Arial,sans-serif]“It’s pretty awful, It totally lost the message,” said a Green party spokesman, adding that representations are being made to Channel 4 about the mistake.[/font]
[font=Geneva,Arial,sans-serif]Channel 4 said overlaying the Ukip subtitles was a genuine mistake that was rectified during the broadcast, which began at 7.55pm in a prime slot after the network’s flagship news bulletin.[/font]
[font=Geneva,Arial,sans-serif]“It was a rare and honest mistake. The subtitles were stopped before the end of the programme and replaced with an apology. Only a small percentage of viewers would have been affected,” a spokesman added.[/font]
[font=Geneva,Arial,sans-serif]The Green spokesman said Channel 4 told his party that the erroneous subtitles – which ran for three of the broadcast’s five minutes – were added as a result of “human error” at BBC Broadcast, the company responsible for adding the subtitles. However, the Green election broadcast shown on other channels had the correct subtitles.[/font]
[font=Geneva,Arial,sans-serif]He added that Channel 4 said it would have to consult its lawyers as to whether the broadcast could be reshown because of the strict rules governing party election broadcasts to ensure fairness.[/font]
[font=Geneva,Arial,sans-serif]Channel 4 was unable to say if any redress will be made to the Green party.[/font]
[font=Geneva,Arial,sans-serif]The Greens – in common with other small parties such as Ukip and the British National party – are only entitled to one election broadcast, unlike the three afforded to the main parties. The election broadcast represents a single – and therefore vital – opportunity to attract voters.[/font]
[font=Geneva,Arial,sans-serif]Ukip is delighted with the mix-up, however. Its own election broadcast will be screened tonight and a spokesman for the party said he hoped the extra, albeit erroneous, exposure its policies received will help attract a few more votes.[/font]
[font=Geneva,Arial,sans-serif]“We’re not letting [the Greens] put their subtitles on our broadcast, though. Although we have a green octopus in our broadcast. It swims up the Thames and swallows the Houses of Parliament,” he added.[/font]
that is a proper disaster- think of all the confused deaf people, coming round to the green party, must have been well wierd…
its so ridiculous, i wonder if it was an accident, if you were gonna subtitle one partys message with another, you couldn’t get more opposing veiws…
poor old grrens, eh?
its so ridiculous, i wonder if it was an accident, if you were gonna subtitle one partys message with another, you couldn’t get more opposing veiws…
poor old grrens, eh?
I don’t think anyone at Auntie would have done it deliberately (I’ve always considered the BBC to be fairly liberal and pro-Europe) – its more an indictment of the current management practices there….
there are shitloads of rendundancies planned, people are working long hours and many parts of the BBC are “privatised” and compete for work with the commercial media sector (why else would Auntie be TX’ing C4s subtitles?)
the workers there are constantly being pressured to produce more for less and in a quicker time frame, and to work on multiple projects at the same time.
In any industry this results in corners being cut – probably they confused the index numbers of the subtitle files (which if the UKIP and Green’s PPBs were made around the same time would have meant that the numbers would be fairly similar) – and didn’t check the TX output package properly.
I’ve noticed a massive drop in quality on all broadcast media recently ; the programmes are full of duff out of focus shots, bad edits, and on the broadcasters websites there’s loads of missing content and bad spelling – its as if noone gives a flying fuck any more (perhaps understandable if they studied for ages and competed hard for a scarce number of jobs, only to find they are being made redundant because some indie will do they job cheaper, propped up by 70 hour week workaholics and unpaid interns.)
I definitely think the Greens should get another free PPB and financial compensation for the damage to their “brand” – if this does not happen I will post contact details for Ofcom here so people can complain….
0
Voices
1
Reply
Tags
This topic has no tags
Forums › Life › Politics, Media & Current Events › UK : Greens PPB trashed by media incompetence