Forums › Life › Film & Television › UK : Ofcom stick up for TV chefs hassled by armchair whingers…
I don’t personally think much of these TV chefs; but they are good cooks and popular entertainers; they are also a main source of education to many people as to where food comes from and how it is prepared.
however it is spun eating meat involves taking the life of a living creature – and this is what these chefs were wanting to show.. where food really commes from…
Some (often those with extra time, money and sources of alternative nutrients) choose not to eat meat; others (such as myself) do but take every precaution possible to ensure our meat is sourced from suppliers with high animal welfare standards.
considering so much other telly is adverts for processed meat products which not only hide their animal origins ; and worse still programmes are broadcast as “entertainment” which glorify violence against our fellow humans (and the environment), I don’t think the chefs ever had a case to answer…
[FONT=Arial,Helvetica,sans-serif]
TV watchdog clears slaughter scenes[/FONT] [FONT=Geneva,Arial,sans-serif] Press Association
Monday January 9, 2006 3:29 PM[/FONT]
[FONT=Geneva,Arial,sans-serif]TV chefs Gordon Ramsay and Jamie Oliver have escaped censure by watchdogs for slaughtering animals on their shows.
Viewers were left distressed when Oliver slit a lamb’s throat on his series Jamie’s Great Escape. And an episode of Ramsay’s programme The F Word provoked a similar response when it featured a slaughterman killing six turkeys the chef had reared in his garden.
Both chefs said they wanted to illustrate where the food on our table comes from. Media regulator Ofcom ruled both Channel 4 shows had treated the issue in a “responsible” way and had not breached TV guidelines.
Between them the shows attracted 57 complaints to Ofcom.
The offending episode of Jamie’s Great Escape was shown on November 9 and began half an hour before the watershed.
Oliver visited an Italian hill farmer who invited him to select a lamb and slaughter it for a family feast.
Ofcom said in its report: “It was clear from the programme that the presenter found it emotionally difficult to carry out his task but the lamb did not struggle or make any distressing noises. There was almost no blood shown and, arguably, it was hard to see what was happening at all.”
The report went on: “We consider that the programme treated the matter responsibly and informatively. There were no graphic distressing scenes and the programme sought to reflect a tradition that has been going on throughout the world, and in that particular part of Italy, for thousands of years.”
Ramsay’s turkey slaughter was broadcast on December 15. He did not kill the birds himself but invited a slaughterman into his garden to kill them with stun guns.
“In our view, the issue as a whole was treated in a responsible and professional way,” Ofcom said.
© Copyright Press Association Ltd 2006, All Rights Reserved.
[/FONT]
[FONT=Geneva,Arial,sans-serif]
[/FONT]
I heard about the Gordon Ramsey show from a friend who saw it.
I think the whole thing is another axample of clueless public.
Better not show how high quality, free range meat is made, better just carry on drinking your Coca Cola and eating McDonalds and be blissfully unaware of real life…
As for the Jamie Oliver one, I think I probably would have complained, not because of the slaughtered lamb, but just because I find him offensive…
(Though I did excercise my right NOT TO WATCH THE FUCKING TELLY!!!)
being a vegetarian myself (and not actually having extra time or money though!)…it annoys me that people who eat meat actually get offended when they are shown face to face where it’s come from! Its a strange form of delusion! 😛
I think the whole thing is another axample of clueless public.
Better not show how high quality, free range meat is made, better just carry on drinking your Coca Cola and eating McDonalds and be blissfully unaware of real life…
As for the Jamie Oliver one, I think I probably would have complained, not because of the slaughtered lamb, but just because I find him offensive…
(Though I did excercise my right NOT TO WATCH THE FUCKING TELLY!!!)
good one
i used to work in a massive meat factory for a few weeks years ago when i was desperate for a job
if people were offended by seeing a lamb being slaughtered, they should see the inside of the place whetre i worked
i haven’t eaten supermarket meat since… the aminals were born / hatched in the factory. all their feed was produced in the factory. they never saw daylight or left their cages.
it was properly offensive… should stick it on the TV and cause some outrage (and vomiting )
it was properly offensive… should stick it on the TV and cause some outrage (and vomiting )
indeed I think the BBC have run a few documentaries of this nature but they have to deal with the whingers as well and are increasingly coming under the influence of ofcom as well (this didn’t happen with the old regulatory regime)
the commercial stations don’t have the power to do so.
although there are a few high earners the TV industry is dying on its arse, theres less money in it than the 1980s or even 1990s, companies are folding left right and centre and those which survive are depending on cheap formats like reality shows and disposable celebs/wannabes
how many ads on ITV or C4/C5 are for processed meat products? if all those ads were pulled so much money would be lost we’d be going back to seeing the testcard in the morning as there would be so much less money for TV programmes (wouldn’t be a bad thing though if the remaining shows were better) – then again the TV company executives aren’t going to let the truth get in the way of their revenue stream…
0
Voices
3
Replies
Tags
This topic has no tags
Forums › Life › Film & Television › UK : Ofcom stick up for TV chefs hassled by armchair whingers…